Monster hunter threads in "Playable Games"

[FelixWan]

i am just wondering would it be better to merge the threads of different version with same Compatibility.

since now the forum contains 3 threads on the same version with different language. But those versions should all have same core which share same compatibility.

related threads:

Monster Hunter Freedom Unite EU
http://forums.ppsspp.org/showthread.php?tid=1095

Monster Hunter Portable 2nd G
http://forums.ppsspp.org/showthread.php?tid=1927

Monster Hunter Freedom Unite US
http://forums.ppsspp.org/showthread.php?tid=887

[Ritori]

I think it should be separate because different region got different bug...

[mupralsh]

Yup, just like Ritori said.
Well i actually answered this same question three times by now.

(08-22-2013 12:15 AM)mupralsh Wrote:  I've talked about this with livisor and other mods, we should keep a different thread for different region of the same game since they sometimes behave really differently on the emu

Moved.

[vnctdj]

But Monster Hunter games are fairly all the same... This is a particularity...
So I would agree to merge the threads that FelixWan has mentioned in his post

[FelixWan]

(09-07-2013 01:06 AM)Ritori Wrote:  I think it should be separate because different region got different bug...

at the moment
i don't see any critical bug or specified compatibility problem on one single version.
in other word, all save data are common for these 3 versions and if a problem occur in one version, it also occurs in other versions as tested before
That's what i mean by "game core"

actually, i found most of the discussion in the board is focused in the thread EU, but i dont think all players in the EU thread is playing EU XD
at least not me

[vnctdj]

So, I think we should merge these threads
As a MHFU player, what do you think FelixWan ?
I will add a poll to this thread

[mupralsh]

(09-08-2013 12:49 AM)FelixWan Wrote:  

(09-07-2013 01:06 AM)Ritori Wrote:  I think it should be separate because different region got different bug...

at the moment
i don't see any critical bug or specified compatibility problem on one single version.
in other word, all save data are common for these 3 versions and if a problem occur in one version, it also occurs in other versions as tested before
That's what i mean by "game core"

actually, i found most of the discussion in the board is focused in the thread EU, but i dont think all players in the EU thread is playing EU XD
at least not me

Ah, it might be better to merge it (for this game) then.
Our consideration back then is, there's some games, like Naruto (EUR) that behaves really differently than the JP counterpart, in that case it should be better to have it on different threads to make the discussion-and reports less confusing.
When the compatibility or the issue is exactly the same, then i also think it should be better to have it on a single thread, it makes the forum cleaner too, so i'll vote 'yes'.

[Ritori]

How about Monster Hunter Portable 3rd?(menu/intro*)
what this thread new name then?
If mod said so, it okay to merge

[vnctdj]

(09-08-2013 11:32 AM)Ritori Wrote:  How about Monster Hunter Portable 3rd?(menu/intro*)

This game is really different

[FelixWan]

(09-08-2013 11:32 AM)Ritori Wrote:  How about Monster Hunter Portable 3rd?(menu/intro*)
what this thread new name then?
If mod said so, it okay to merge

it's totally different
3rd portable is encrypted....

the main graphic things should not have much different though...

[Ritori]

I notice you guy put poll there :o
I hate vote thing but never mind then

[TheDax]

I voted no. What if one region or another ends up having its own issue? Then you can't split it off very easily from the main game's thread anymore.

And no, don't merge MH3rd with MH3rd HD. They're two separate games with their own issues.

[vnctdj]

(09-08-2013 12:44 PM)daxtsu Wrote:  I voted no. What if there's a chance that one region or another ends up having its own issue? Then you can't split it off very easily from the main game's thread anymore.

By now, all the issues appeared in both EU and US versions
And if ever there is an issue which appear in only one version, we can always create a new thread for that, but in my opinion, this will not arrive...

(09-08-2013 12:44 PM)daxtsu Wrote:  And no, don't merge MH3rd with MH3rd HD. They're two separate games with their own issues.

No problem about that

---

With some thoughts, I think that the Japanese version of the game (MHP2nd G) shouldn't be merged with the EU version and the US version.

It has some differences (more content for example), this is more than just a different region of the game

To conclude, I think that we should merge the EU and the US version of MHFU

[TheDax]

That'd be fine. 2nd G is to MHFU as God Eater Burst is to God Eater, so to speak. IIRC 2nd G has more items like the lobster set(pirate set? something like that) while MHFU actually has a few less items.

[FelixWan]

(09-08-2013 01:32 PM)vnctdj Wrote:  With some thoughts, I think that the Japanese version of the game (MHP2nd G) shouldn't be merged with the EU version and the US version.

It has some differences (more content for example), this is more than just a different region of the game

To conclude, I think that we should merge the EU and the US version of MHFU

2nd G also contains Korean version... (and also "patched" Chinese/English version )

although Freedom unite seems deleted quite a number of components compare with 2nd G, we are now concern about the point of compatibility. I don't think the compatibility of a game would variant a lot in this case since they are all obviously having same game engine.

that's y i suggested to merge all those threads.