Retro vs Modern?

[ZeroX4]

ok let me put it this way

why moder sonic fails and modern zelda wins?

they did the same thing with this games but 1 fails and other did perfect job but why?

here is my opinion about what went wrong or what was wrong from the start

1st sonic games what they was about?
-running right or left but fast
-collecting rings
-jumping and killing

1st zelda games what they was about?
-story
-gannon
-ZELDA
-weapons/items
-and of course killing monsters/bosses

now look what changed in both games?
from 2D to 3D

and why it worked bad for sonic and not for zelda?

cause zelda games was never was based on 1 or 2 factors i mentioned above zelda games was always based on many fctors this ones
-story
-ZELDA
-weapons/items
-and of course killing monsters/bosses

and sonic ? what was making this game awesome?
-running right or left but fast
-collecting rings
-jumping and killing

but but what was so iconic for sonic games?
-running right or left but fast

and when it was gone replaced with storyline dialogues NEW/DIFFERENT gameplay style fans ware mad cause it was like totally different game not like next generation of sonic games

and in my opinion thats why zelda didnt fail and sonic did

and same for mario games there was a reason why yoshi islad was called youshi island and not mario & yoshi adventure